Gestalt vs Existential Therapy: Understanding Key Differences

Written By

Saba Imran

Fact Checked

A person sitting in a room, torn between two paths, one leading to integration and wholeness, the other to finding meaning and purpose in their existence

Note: This post is supported by our readers and contains affiliate links, which will earn us a small commission at no extra cost to you. Therapy Helpers does not accept money for reviews.

When it comes to understanding different psychotherapies, Gestalt and Existential therapies stand out for their unique approaches and objectives.

Although both belong to the humanistic school of therapy and emphasize personal growth, they diverge significantly in their methods and focus areas.

Gestalt therapy concentrates on the present moment and personal responsibility.

It encourages clients to become more aware of their immediate thoughts and feelings, which can help them deal with current challenges more effectively.

On the other hand, Existential therapy dives into broader questions about life, purpose, and meaning, prompting clients to explore their place in the world and confront aspects of the human condition.

For those deciding between these therapies, it’s important to understand that Gestalt therapy is more focused on present experiences, while Existential therapy deals with life’s bigger questions.

Each therapy offers different tools and techniques, making them suitable for varying personal challenges and goals.

Key Takeaways

  • Gestalt therapy focuses on present moment awareness and personal responsibility.
  • Existential therapy explores questions of life, purpose, and meaning.
  • Each therapy has unique methods suitable for different personal challenges.


Historical Context and Key Philosophies

YouTube video

Gestalt and Existential therapies emerged from unique historical contexts and philosophies.

Both approaches center around personal responsibility and human experience but have different roots and key figures.

Ad, keeps our community free. The perspectives presented on this website are genuinely our own and we do not accept money for reviews.

Onlinetherapycom Logo
talkspace review

4.8 (4,147+) From Online-Therapy.com

Fill out a brief questionnaire and get matched with a licensed therapist online within 24 hours.

✓ Experienced professional therapists only

✓ You can message your therapist 24/7

✓ Plans as low as $40/week, billed every four weeks

✓ Financial aid available

20% off through Therapy Helpers

Foundations of Gestalt Therapy

Gestalt therapy originated in the 1940s and 1950s, developed by Fritz Perls, Laura Perls, and Paul Goodman.

It is based on Gestalt psychology, which emphasizes the human ability to perceive patterns and wholes.

Gestalt therapy focuses on personal responsibility, awareness, and the present moment.

It integrates psychoanalytic ideas from Freud while emphasizing the importance of the “here and now.”

The approach encourages clients to explore their thoughts, feelings, and actions in the present, fostering greater self-awareness and personal growth.

Key Proponents of Existential Therapy

Existential therapy is grounded in existentialism, a philosophical movement that explores human existence, freedom, and choice.

Important figures include Victor Frankl, who developed logotherapy, and other thinkers influenced by existential philosophy.

Victor Frankl’s work emphasized finding meaning in life, even in suffering.

Existential therapy does not follow a strict methodology but rather focuses on understanding the client’s subjective experience.

It encourages individuals to confront the givens of existence such as death, freedom, isolation, and meaninglessness to live more authentically.

Existential therapy also draws from the works of philosophers like Kierkegaard, Nietzsche, and Sartre, stressing personal responsibility and the quest for meaning.

Theoretical Frameworks

YouTube video

Gestalt and existential therapies differ significantly in their approaches and goals.

Gestalt therapy focuses on present awareness and self-regulation, while existential therapy emphasizes free will and the quest for life’s meaning.

Principles of Gestalt Therapy

Gestalt therapy centers on the here and now. It emphasizes the importance of current experiences and personal responsibility.

The Field Theory is crucial in this approach, suggesting that an individual’s context affects their experiences and behaviors.

The Figure-Formation Process is another key concept. It explains how people organize their perception, focusing on what stands out (figure) against the background (ground).

This helps clients become aware of their needs and how to address them.

Organismic Self-Regulation is also fundamental. It refers to the process where individuals identify and satisfy their genuine needs rather than conforming to external pressures.

This enables clients to lead more authentic lives.

Ad, keeps our community free. The perspectives presented on this website are genuinely our own and we do not accept money for reviews.

Onlinetherapycom Logo
talkspace review

4.8 (4,147+) From Online-Therapy.com

Fill out a brief questionnaire and get matched with a licensed therapist online within 24 hours.

✓ Experienced professional therapists only

✓ You can message your therapist 24/7

✓ Plans as low as $40/week, billed every four weeks

✓ Financial aid available

20% off through Therapy Helpers

Fundamentals of Existential Therapy

Existential therapy revolves around the idea of finding meaning in life. It asserts that individuals have the freedom to shape their own lives through choices and actions.

This therapy often deals with existential questions about love, death, and the meaning of life.

A significant component is the focus on self-determination. Therapists guide clients to recognize their capacity for self-direction and the consequences of their choices.

Existential therapy also deals with free will and personal responsibility.

It helps clients confront the anxiety that comes with freedom and isolation. By facing these universal human concerns, individuals can live more meaningful and fulfilled lives.

For more detailed information, you can refer to Different approaches to psychotherapy and Existential theory and therapy.

Therapeutic Goals and Interventions

A serene landscape with two paths diverging, one representing Gestalt therapy and the other existential therapy, with a peaceful and harmonious ambiance

Therapeutic goals and interventions in Gestalt and existential therapy center on personal growth, awareness, and a meaningful therapeutic relationship.

Both methods emphasize personal responsibility, but their approaches differ in the execution of these goals.

Goals in Gestalt Therapy

Gestalt therapy emphasizes awareness and personal growth.

The main goal is for clients to become more aware of their actions and feelings in the present moment.

This awareness allows clients to make conscious choices and changes in their lives.

Therapists encourage clients to take personal responsibility for their reactions and behaviors.

By doing so, clients can identify how they project their issues onto others and how they can reclaim control over their lives.

Key interventions include the use of experiments and role-playing.

These activities help clients explore their emotions and behaviors in a safe environment.

For instance, a client may be asked to act out a recurring conflict to understand its root cause better.

Existential Therapy Aims

Existential therapy focuses on the search for meaning and personal responsibility.

The primary aim is to help clients find meaning in their lives despite inherent challenges such as isolation, freedom, and mortality.

Clients are encouraged to confront existential anxiety and explore their values and beliefs.

This helps them make meaningful choices aligned with their true selves.

Therapists work to establish a therapeutic relationship based on empathy and authenticity.

Clients are supported in their journey of self-discovery and acceptance.

Techniques such as open-ended dialogue and reflective listening are commonly used to facilitate meaningful conversations.

Clients are encouraged to take an active role in their personal growth, making conscious and responsible choices aligned with their values.

Therapeutic Techniques and Exercises

YouTube video

Gestalt therapy uses various exercises to bring self-awareness and present-focused living to clients, while existential therapy emphasizes personal freedom and choices by confronting life’s inherent challenges.

Core Gestalt Exercises

One of the primary methods in Gestalt therapy is the Empty Chair technique.

In this exercise, clients visualize speaking to a part of themselves or another person. This helps them express and process unresolved emotions.

Another key exercise is the Exaggeration Exercise.

Clients are asked to exaggerate a physical movement or gesture. This makes them more aware of subtle body language and underlying emotions.

The Internal Dialogue Exercise involves clients having a conversation between conflicting parts of themselves.

This promotes self-awareness and resolution of inner conflicts.

Dream Work is another tool. Clients recount a dream and relive it in the present moment, gaining insight into hidden thoughts and feelings.

In Staying with the Feeling, clients focus on and intensify a specific feeling they are experiencing.

This helps them fully understand and process their emotions.

Finally, professionals often use Experiments, which are spontaneous and creative activities tailored to individual clients to explore behaviors and reactions in the moment.

Intervention Strategies in Existential Therapy

Existential therapy encourages clients to face life’s big questions and make meaningful choices.

One method includes fostering an awareness of death, which helps clients appreciate life’s preciousness and motivates them to live more fully.

Choice of living is another critical strategy.

Clients explore different ways of living and make conscious choices about how they engage with the world, instead of passively accepting their circumstances.

Handling existential anxiety is also a key focus.

Clients learn to manage the anxiety that comes with confronting life’s uncertainties and finding personal meaning.

Therapists might use reflective exercises where clients discuss their feelings about freedom, responsibility, and isolation, fostering a deeper understanding of themselves and their place in the world.

These strategies are designed to help clients accept the realities of human existence and find purposeful ways to live despite them.

Applications and Efficacy

Two puzzle pieces fitting together, representing the integration of Gestalt and existential therapy approaches

Gestalt and existential therapies offer unique approaches to mental health treatment, focusing on present experiences and personal growth.

These therapies aim to address various psychological issues like anxiety, depression, and relationship difficulties.

Clinical Applications of Gestalt Therapy

Gestalt therapy centers on heightened self-awareness and understanding the “here and now.”

It’s frequently used for dealing with anxiety, depression, and communication issues.

Therapists encourage clients to explore their feelings, thoughts, and actions in the present moment.

This therapy often involves role-playing and other exercises that promote personal growth and self-efficacy.

Moreover, this approach can help individuals with low self-esteem and relationship difficulties by fostering greater emotional insight and healthier interactions.

Specific techniques include the “empty chair” method and guided imagery, which help clients uncover unresolved feelings and enhance personal responsibility.

Effectiveness of Existential Therapy

Existential therapy emphasizes making meaningful choices and confronting life’s inherent uncertainties.

It’s particularly effective for those struggling with feelings of resentment, low self-esteem, and existential crises often linked to health problems or major life changes.

This therapy encourages clients to find personal meaning and take responsibility for their actions.

Research has shown it to be beneficial for treating depression and anxiety.

It helps clients navigate complicated emotions and improve their sense of autonomy and self-efficacy.

Therapists work collaboratively with clients to explore their values, beliefs, and goals, enhancing overall personal growth and well-being.

For more detailed information, view the Existential and CBT Approaches article or read about the effectiveness of Gestalt therapy.

Frequently Asked Questions

Two chairs facing each other, one with "Gestalt Therapy" written on it and the other with "Existential Therapy." A question mark hovers between them

Gestalt and existential therapies both aim to enhance self-awareness and personal growth.

What are the core differences in the therapeutic approaches of Gestalt and existential therapies?

Gestalt therapy focuses on the present moment and awareness. It encourages clients to experience their current feelings and behaviors.

Existential therapy, on the other hand, deals with the human condition as a whole. It explores themes like freedom, responsibility, and finding meaning in life.

How do Gestalt therapy techniques compare with those used in existential therapy?

Gestalt therapy uses experiential techniques. Examples include role-playing and the “empty chair” technique to bring emotions into the present.

Existential therapy emphasizes dialogue and deep reflection. This helps clients face existential issues such as isolation, death, and freedom.

Can you delineate the similarities that exist between Gestalt and existential therapies?

Both therapies focus on self-awareness and personal experience. They encourage clients to take responsibility for their actions.

Each approach values the client’s perspective and inner experiences. They both help clients understand themselves better and make meaningful life changes.

In what ways is Gestalt therapy distinct from humanistic and existential therapies?

Gestalt therapy specifically targets present-moment awareness and integration of experiences. Humanistic therapy, including Client-centered therapy, focuses on a supportive therapeutic relationship.

Both humanistic and existential therapies explore personal growth and self-actualization, but existential therapy delves deeper into existential themes.

What is the relationship between mindfulness practices and Gestalt therapeutic techniques?

Mindfulness practices and Gestalt therapy both stress present-moment awareness.

In Gestalt therapy, clients learn to notice their immediate thoughts and feelings. This is very similar to mindfulness techniques that promote staying present and fully engaged in the moment.

How does the theoretical underpinning of Gestalt therapy differ from that of person-centered therapy?

Gestalt therapy is rooted in the idea of holism and experience. It believes in integrating different parts of oneself for better awareness.

Person-centered therapy, founded by Carl Rogers, emphasizes unconditional positive regard and empathy to foster personal growth. Both therapies prioritize the client’s experience but use different methodologies.

Looking for more mental health tips? Make sure to follow our Mental Health Board on Pinterest!

Recommended Insights:

A serene office in Boston with soft lighting and comfortable seating, a therapist's diploma on the wall, and a warm and welcoming atmosphere

How to Find Empath Therapist in Boston: A Comprehensive Guide

Seeking an empath therapist in Boston? Discover compassionate professionals who offer personalized mental health support.
A serene coastal landscape in Croatia with a laptop and a comfortable chair, symbolizing the setting for online therapy

Online Therapy in Croatia: Exploring Its Growing Popularity and Benefits

Discover the best online therapy options in Croatia, offering expert support and convenience for mental well-being.
A peaceful cityscape of Chicago with a serene park and a cozy office building, suggesting a calm and empathetic therapist

How to Find Empath Therapist in Chicago: A Comprehensive Guide

Seeking an empath therapist in Chicago? Discover compassionate professionals who offer personalized mental health support.

About the author

Saba Imran

Saba Imran

I'm passionate about medical research and writing. I earned my Master's degree in Microbiology because I love learning about tiny microbes and how they impact health. With over 7 years experience as a healthcare researcher and medical writer, I've published many times in international journals. Participating in research projects has given me in-depth knowledge to make complex topics easy to grasp. In my free time, I volunteer at the community science museum to get kids excited about science and discovery. My goal is to take difficult concepts and make them understandable through meticulous research, hopefully benefiting people across the globe. I believe clear science writing can empower us all. Social

6 thoughts on “Gestalt vs Existential Therapy: Understanding Key Differences”

  1. Really appreciated how this article broke down the differences between gestalt and existential therapy! I’ve been in gestalt therapy for a few months but was curious about existential approaches. The comparison of how gestalt focuses on the ‘here and now’ while existential deals with deeper meaning really clicked for me.

    Reply
  2. Helped me understand why my therapist keeps bringing me back to present moment awareness instead of dwelling on past patterns. The examples of typical sessions in each style were super helpful too. Still sticking with gestalt for now, but great to understand the options out there.”

    Reply
  3. As someone who’s tried both, this article really highlights the key differences. Found Gestalt’s ‘here and now’ focus transformative for my anxiety, while my friend connected more with existential therapy’s deeper exploration of meaning. Neither is better – just different paths for different needs. Great comparison!

    Reply
  4. Really interesting comparison! I’ve been curious about the differences between Gestalt and existential therapy, and this article explained it so clearly. It’s helpful to see how each approach works and which might resonate more depending on personal needs. Great read!

    Reply
  5. Thank you for sharing superb informations. Your web-site is so cool. I am impressed by the details that you have on this site. It reveals how nicely you understand this subject. Bookmarked this web page, will come back for more articles. You, my pal, ROCK! I found just the info I already searched all over the place and just couldn’t come across. What a great web-site.

    Reply

Leave a Comment